Mystery Box Price at Tim Hortons (2026)
A Mystery Box from Tim Hortons in United States is $3.11 (October 2026 pricing).
Looking up the Mystery Box price at Tim Hortons in the United States? It currently sells for $3.11. That's about 49% above the typical Tim Hortons Baked Good item — the 10th-most-expensive of 60 we track. It's available at around 40 Tim Hortons locations across the United States. Prices are sourced from delivery platforms and refreshed regularly. Browse the latest Tim Hortons Baked Good prices and find the cheapest pick on MenuPriceToday.
How this compares in Baked Goods
60 items tracked| This item | $3.11 |
| Baked Goods median | $2.09 |
| Cheapest — Key Lime Timbit | $0.48 |
| Most expensive — Muffin Multi-Pack | $13.77 |
| vs Baked Goods median | +49% |
Compare Tim Hortons prices across 20+ countries — Fast-Food Price Index →